Should you “dispute” your accounts?
July 30th 2011
Everyone has the right to dispute an account on their credit report if they think that the account has been reported incorrectly or has an error on it. Part of the process is that when you dispute an account, the bureaus can’t use that derogatory information to lower your credit score until the issue is resolved. Well we humans have a natural tendency to take advantage of loopholes that are intended to help, so people started abusing the system by disputing any and all derogatory accounts regardless of the true or false nature of the reporting. The problem is that the “dispute” tag does not always get removed once the dispute has been settled. It is stuck to many accounts even ones that have been paid off and closed for years. Common sense says that an account that is paid and closed is not being disputed anymore, doesn’t it?
Now I don’t know about other industries, but the mortgage business decided that the abuse was too much of a risk so most Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, conventional lenders have implemented a flat policy that they will not lend to a borrower that has ANY disputed accounts on their credit report. If you have a “dispute” tag on any of your accounts and you want to get a conventional loan, you have to get a letter from the original creditor that states that they will report to the credit bureaus that the account is no longer disputed. The letter itself is not good enough. So you can go about this one of two ways, you can wait the 30 to 60 days it takes for the creditor to report to the bureaus or you pay for a service that can get it reported in 3 to 4 days. Some companies call this Rescore Express and others call it Rapid Rescore. You send in the letter to a credit reporting company and they go to the bureuas and get the “dispute” tag taken off.
So you want to use a conventional loan (FHA loans do not have this “dispute” problem) and you find out you have a dispute on an account, so you call the creditor to get the letter. If the account is old and closed, the creditor does not have a huge motivation to send you that letter but let’s assume you get it.. You send it in for the quick rescore service and they send it in to the bureaus. Now the problem comes up that certain bureaus have to verify the letter with a phone call but your creditor has a policy that they do not give out that information over the phone. Now you have a problem. The bureau has to have a verification but your creditor won’t play well with others. I am currently working with a borrower that is going through this exact problem. They disputed an account 8 years ago and eventually paid it off but the dispute was never removed. They are a good credit risk. They have a good income and low debt but they are stuck in this bureaucratic catch22.
So if you want a conventional loan and you have any disputes on your credit report please start the process of getting those removed or you will have to go with an FHA loan.
Let me know if you have any questions or if I can help.















